top of page
Blog: Blog2

Stop Just Looking for New Donors. Start Looking at Your Old Ones.

Writer: Ted Priestly
Ted Priestly
Oct 26
4 min read

Why Every Coach and Organization Should Review Their LYBUNTs and SYBUNTs


When it comes to fundraising, coaches and organizations often spend so much time trying to find new donors that they overlook one of their greatest opportunities: the people who have already supported them.


Before you launch your next fundraising campaign, take a few minutes to review two important groups of people in your donor database: your LYBUNTs and SYBUNTs.


If those terms are unfamiliar, you’re not alone. But understanding them could make a significant difference in your fundraising success.


What Are LYBUNTs and SYBUNTs?


LYBUNT = Last Year But Unfortunately Not This Year

These are donors who contributed to your program last year but have not yet made a gift this year.


SYBUNT = Some Year But Unfortunately Not This Year

These are donors who supported your program at some point in the past, but have not yet contributed this year. This broader group can include your LYBUNTs.


Both groups represent tremendous opportunities because they have already demonstrated something incredibly valuable: a willingness to support your organization.


They know who you are. They understand your mission. And, at some point, they believed in what you were doing enough to make a financial contribution.


That’s a pretty good starting point!


Why Aren’t They Giving Anymore?

Here’s something important to remember: Just because someone hasn’t donated recently doesn’t mean they’ve lost interest in your program.


  • Maybe you didn't thank them - or you thanked them poorly.

  • Perhaps they weren’t asked again.

  • Maybe they missed your last campaign.

  • Maybe their contact information changed.

  • Perhaps they felt disconnected from the program or simply had other financial priorities.


Don’t assume someone has stopped caring just because they’ve stopped giving.

In many cases, all it takes is a personal phone call, email, or conversation to reconnect. You ask a lot of your student-athletes - it's now ON YOU to live up to what you say, and do the little things that add up to the big picture.


In the Greater Boston area, we have a term for this. It's called, 'THANKING BETTAH!'


If your donors have not been thanked, or thanked well in the past, admit that (especially if you are new to the program), and assure them that things are going to change...and then live up to that promise!


Five Reasons to Revisit Your Past Donors:


1. They’re Already Familiar With Your Program.

Unlike prospective donors who may know little about your organization, LYBUNTs and SYBUNTs already have a connection. You don’t have to start the relationship from scratch.


2. Reconnecting Can Be More Efficient Than Recruiting.

Finding and cultivating new donors takes time and effort. Reengaging someone who has already contributed can be a more efficient way to generate support.


3. It’s an Opportunity to Say Thank You.

Your first communication shouldn’t necessarily be another request for money. Thank them for their previous generosity. Tell them what their support helped accomplish. Make them feel appreciated.


4. You Can Rebuild Relationships.

Fundraising isn’t simply about transactions. It’s about relationships. Reconnecting with former donors creates opportunities to share updates, invite them to events, and help them feel part of your program again.


5. Small Improvements Can Produce Meaningful Results.

Imagine your organization has 100 previous donors who haven’t contributed this year.

If just 25 of them return with an average gift of $100, that’s an additional $2,500 for your program.


And that’s without identifying a single new donor!


Coaches: Here’s Your Homework!

Before your next fundraising campaign, ask your athletic department, booster club, development office, or fundraising coordinator to help you identify your LYBUNTs and SYBUNTs.


Then:

  1. Review the names. Identify former athletes, parents, alumni, friends, and community supporters who previously contributed.

  2. Prioritize personal relationships. Determine who on your coaching staff or within your organization has an existing connection with each donor.

  3. Reach out personally. A phone call or personalized email can mean much more than another mass solicitation.

  4. Share your progress. Let donors know what your program has accomplished and where you’re headed.

  5. Invite them back. Give them an opportunity to reconnect, participate, and support your program again.


And remember, not every conversation needs to end with a donation. Sometimes rebuilding the relationship is the most important first step.


The Bottom Line

At Fundraise4U, we believe that successful fundraising begins with relationships, not transactions.


Too often, organizations focus exclusively on acquiring new donors while overlooking the people who have already invested in their success.


Your former donors are more than names on a spreadsheet. They’re people who once believed in your mission, supported your athletes, and helped move your organization forward.


Don’t spend all your time looking for your next donor when that person might already be in your database.


Review your LYBUNTs. Review your SYBUNTs. Pick up the phone. Reconnect. Say thank you.

You might be surprised by how many people are willing to support you again.



undraising solutions for organizations that need to raise money, but either don't know how, or don't have the time or resources required to do it well..

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page